Google Search is undergoing a seismic transformation.
Advances in generative AI are turning the search engine into an “answer engine” – providing instant answers and summaries that often remove the need to click traditional search results.
In Google’s experimental Search Generative Experience (SGE), an AI-generated summary now appears at the very top of the results page, pushing the familiar blue links further down.
Google itself describes SGE as delivering “rapid and concise overviews of search topics” right on the results page, so users get what they need without having to click through to websites.
Unsurprisingly, this has huge implications for any business that relies on search traffic – and law firms are no exception.
Comparison of a traditional Google results page (left) versus the new AI-driven Search Generative Experience page (right).
In the SGE example, significantly more screen space is occupied by Google’s own AI summary and other rich features (highlighted in yellow), while the familiar organic website listings (green) are pushed much further down the page.
A New Look for Google’s Results: More Answers, Fewer Clicks
Today’s Google results pages look very different from a few years ago. They are dominated by rich features – AI snapshots, featured snippets, knowledge panels, image carousels, maps, “People Also Ask” questions – all appearing before the first organic link. In the SGE trial, Google’s AI synopsis can occupy the entire top portion of the screen, which drastically reduces the visibility of traditional organic listings. As one industry analysis put it, “there is far more screen real estate dedicated to Google’s search features and less available for organic and paid search results” in an AI-driven SERP. In other words, your website link might now show up halfway down the page (or lower), below an AI-generated answer box that attempts to satisfy the query on its own.
This shift is feeding a fast-growing “zero-click” phenomenon. A zero-click search is one where the user’s query is answered directly on Google’s page, so they never click through to any website.
Thanks to snippets and AI answers, more than half of Google searches now end without a click. A recent study found nearly 60% of Google searches in 2024 were zero-click – users got their info from Google’s page and didn’t need to visit an external site. And it’s not just informational snippets: Google often prefers to keep users in its own ecosystem (via Google Maps, YouTube, etc.), meaning only a minority of searches result in traffic to third-party websites. Put simply, Google is increasingly answering questions itself, and fewer users are clicking out to the open web.
The Role of SGE: Google’s AI Summary at the Top
Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE) is the clearest example of this transformation. SGE uses generative AI (Google’s large language models like PaLM 2) to answer complex queries in a conversational way, directly on the results page. Ask a multi-faceted question – for example, “what’s the best approach for a family with young kids to handle a minor injury claim?” – and SGE will synthesize an answer drawing from multiple web sources, presented as a cohesive paragraph or two. This AI-generated snapshot appears above the traditional results, often with a few source links cited underneath. It’s essentially Google’s own summary of the “best answer” to the query.
For users, this is a convenient time-saver. For law firms and other businesses, however, SGE is a double-edged sword. On one hand, Google does cite sources in the AI summary, and those citations can drive some clicks if a reader wants more detail. (Google has even stated it is “committed to continue sending valuable traffic to sites across the web” as it rolls out generative search.)
On the other hand, the AI answer itself often suffices, meaning the searcher never needs to click any source. Even when sources are shown, they are in a much less prominent position.
Early data suggests that the links SGE cites aren’t always the top organic results anyway – only 57% of SGE’s cited links come from the first page of results, and in almost half of cases the AI cites a site that wasn’t even in the top 10 traditional results. In fact, the very first link listed by SGE matches the #1 organic result only about 12% of the time. Google’s AI might pull from anywhere, making the traditional page-one ranking less of a guarantee of visibility. The net effect is that SGE and similar AI features are absorbing users’ attention at the expense of organic listings, heralding a world where getting on page one may no longer guarantee traffic.
From SEO to AEO: Optimizing to Be the Answer
These changes have led marketers to coin a new term: Answer Engine Optimization (AEO). If traditional SEO is about boosting your rankings in search results, AEO is about earning a spot in the answers that Google’s AI provides. In practical terms, AEO means structuring your content to directly answer common questions in your field so that Google can easily feature that answer in a snippet or AI overview. Rather than just aiming to have a page rank #1 for “What is the statute of limitations for X?”, for example, a law firm would aim to have a concise, authoritative answer that Google might excerpt for that query. These answers often appear in featured snippets, knowledge cards, the “People Also Ask” dropdowns, or SGE summaries. They give the user immediate information.
How is AEO different from traditional SEO? In essence, SEO focuses on improving your website’s overall visibility (backlinks, technical structure, keywords) to rank higher, whereas AEO zeroes in on intent and context – providing precise answers to specific questions. The goal of AEO isn’t just to rank a page, but to have your content surface in the answer box. For instance, old-school SEO for a personal injury firm might involve a blog post targeting “car accident claim process Florida” and hoping it ranks on page one. An AEO approach would be to directly answer common sub-questions within that content (“How long do I have to file a claim in Florida?”) in a crisp, snippet-friendly format. Google’s algorithms (and AI) prioritize clear, authoritative answers for these rich results. Structuring content with FAQs, concise definitions, step-by-step lists, and schema markup can help the search engine understand and feature your content as an answer.
Crucially, AEO doesn’t replace SEO – it builds upon it. You still need the fundamentals (strong website, good content, backlinks) for Google to trust your site at all. But in an AI-driven search landscape, those fundamentals alone won’t guarantee visibility. You also need to speak the language of the answer engines. Think of AEO as an evolution of SEO: an added layer where you optimize for featured snippets, voice search queries, and AI summary citations. For law firms, that could mean creating more Q&A style content, legal glossaries, or quick-reference guides on common issues (e.g. “What to do after a car accident”) that Google can easily pull into an instant answer. Law firms that master AEO will effectively train Google’s AI to highlight them as authoritative sources.
Zero-Click Searches: Threats to Organic Traffic and Lead Generation
One of the most immediate impacts of this AI-centric search model is on website traffic – the lifeblood of traditional SEO ROI. As noted, over half of searches may now end without a click. For law firms, this trend is alarming: it means potential clients might get the info they need (basic legal definitions, procedure outlines, etc.) straight from Google’s results page, bypassing your website entirely.
Fewer clicks = fewer visitors, which inevitably means fewer opportunities to convert prospects. Good2bSocial, a legal marketing agency, warns that “for law firms, [SGE] means potential clients might find the answers to their legal questions directly on Google, bypassing your website entirely” – improving user experience but posing “significant challenges” for your online visibility and lead generation.
In other words, if people don’t visit your site, they won’t see your detailed case results, your attorney bios, your contact forms – all the things that turn a casual searcher into a real client.
The numbers paint a worrisome picture for organic traffic. Insight Partners, analyzing the impact of SGE, predicts that web traffic to companies could fall significantly as Google shifts toward AI-driven answers.
Their research across various industries estimates that organic search traffic might decline in the range of 15–25% as SGE rolls out. Some SEO experts have noted that we’ve weathered search algorithm changes before without dire consequences, but Insight’s analysis explains why this time is different.
Featured snippets in the past affected a small fraction of searches (~18%) and often still led to clicks, whereas Google is testing SGE on almost all queries (aside from very sensitive topics) and its AI answers give far more comprehensive info upfront.
The click-through rates (CTR) on these AI answers are expected to be much lower than for the old featured snippets.
Plus, SGE encourages follow-up questions in the interface itself, allowing users to dig deeper within Google rather than clicking out. All these factors lead to a scenario where a lot of search traffic that used to flow to websites will now stay on Google.
What does this mean for a law firm’s marketing funnel? Simply put, a hit to web traffic can ripple through every stage of client acquisition.
Fewer visitors means fewer contacts or consultation requests (lead volume drops), which in turn means fewer conversions to actual clients. A briefing by Insight Partners bluntly states: “the evolution towards a zero click world means less traffic coming to your webpage.”
They anticipate search-driven lead quantity will go down, and even downstream effects like retargeting audiences shrinking, since fewer people visit the site to get tagged by your remarketing pixels. Good2bSocial similarly notes that “fewer clicks mean less traffic to your site, which can affect conversion rates… reduced visitors can lead to fewer inquiries and consultations, impacting your firm’s bottom line.”. In other words, the ROI of SEO and content marketing could suffer if you’re measuring it in traditional ways (traffic, leads, conversions) and you fail to adapt to these new realities.
Law firms also invest heavily in paid search (Google Ads) and local SEO, and these too might feel the squeeze. If AI answers reduce the frequency of clicks, even the sponsored links at the top might get fewer eyeballs. (Interestingly, Google has so far kept ads in the SGE environment – they still appear in dedicated slots, albeit fewer of them than on a classic results page.
This suggests Google will find ways to incorporate ads into AI results, but there may be less ad inventory per query, possibly driving up bid competition for the remaining spots.) Meanwhile, for local searches like “estate planning lawyer near me,” Google’s zero-click Local Pack still dominates. If anything, as users get more accustomed to not clicking, ensuring your firm appears in those local map results becomes even more critical – otherwise you risk invisibility even if you rank organically below the map. In short, whether it’s organic SEO or PPC, the traditional pathways for law firms to get in front of prospects are being squeezed by AI-driven answers and Google’s own properties.
Adapting to the AI-Dominated Landscape
The pace of change in search right now is unprecedentedly rapid. Google’s SGE went from announcement to limited rollout in 2023, and all signs indicate a broader release in 2024. Competing AI chatbots (Bing Chat, ChatGPT plugins, etc.) are also pressuring Google to accelerate these features. For law firms, the worst thing you could do is nothing. As one analyst put it, “SGE is coming, and the worst thing you could do is nothing” – businesses should be engaged, proactive, and ready to pivot. In practical terms, adapting means rethinking your digital marketing strategy on multiple fronts:
- Double down on AEO and content optimization for AI – Ensure your site’s content is structured to answer common questions directly. This increases the chance of being the trusted source that Google’s AI cites or features. If, for example, Google’s AI summarizes “How to file a workers’ comp claim,” you want your firm’s insights woven into that answer. This involves using clear headings (questions as H2s/H3s), concise answer paragraphs, bullet lists, and schema markup (like FAQPage schema) so Google can easily digest your content. The firms that thrive will be those that effectively become part of Google’s answer. Even if the user doesn’t click immediately, having your name show up in the AI overview builds brand awareness and credibility – so that if the user does need more or is unsatisfied, your site is the first they’ll consider.
- Monitor and measure new metrics – Traditional SEO success was measured in clicks and traffic. Going forward, impressions and visibility might matter just as much. For example, even if a client doesn’t click your link because Google answered their query, was your firm visible in that answer? Some brands are already reporting increased traffic from AI citations – essentially, people seeing the brand mention in an AI result and later visiting or searching that brand. Law firms should watch for indicators like branded searches (did your name get out there via zero-click answers?), or referral traffic from odd sources (could be from AI chat referrals). Also, track conversion rates carefully – if traffic drops but the remaining visitors are more qualified (which is possible, as those who do click through an AI result may have a more specific intent), you might find conversions holding steady or even improving relative to traffic. ROI evaluation will need to account for these nuances, not just raw visit counts.
- Leverage other channels and formats – With Google siphoning off more top-of-funnel inquiries, smart law firm marketers will broaden their approach. This could mean investing more in local SEO (Google Business Profile optimization, local service ads) since local packs remain a key zero-click element for attracting clients in your vicinity. It also means focusing on brand-building and awareness so that even if prospects don’t click your site initially, they recognize and trust your name when it appears in answers. Some experts even suggest treating Google’s AI answers almost like a new social media feed – one where appearing (even without clicks) has value for mindshare. Additionally, consider channels like YouTube (videos), which can appear in search results, and providing content on Q&A platforms or forums that might be surfaced by AI. Essentially, meet your audience wherever they seek information – not only on your website.
- Keep investing in quality content and expertise – It might be tempting to panic and cut back on SEO content since “Google is stealing clicks,” but that would be a mistake. High-quality, authoritative content is still the currency with which you buy your spot in the AI answers. Google’s algorithms – AI included – reward expertise and trustworthiness (E-E-A-T). Law firms have a natural advantage here if they publish genuinely helpful legal insights. Continue creating content that demonstrates your expertise, whether or not it immediately brings in traffic. Think of it as feeding Google’s AI: if your site provides one of the best answers, that answer could reach clients even if they don’t land on your page directly. And if Google’s summary doesn’t fully address their nuanced situation (which it often won’t, especially for complex legal matters), your firm will be top-of-mind for a click or a call.
In this fast-evolving scenario, the importance of SEO is not disappearing – it’s adapting. As one legal marketing commentator noted, SEO isn’t “dead” at all; in fact, businesses continue to benefit from SEO strategies and there are now many digital touchpoints on a results page (maps, snippets, images, etc.) where a brand can appear. The key is recognizing that the rules of the game have changed. Success in 2025’s search landscape will be defined not just by how high your website ranks, but by how visible your information is within Google’s AI-driven results. Law firms that embrace Answer Engine Optimization, adapt their content strategy, and diversify their digital marketing efforts are likely to still find plenty of opportunities to attract clients. Those that stick to the old playbook – relying solely on the “10 blue links” era tactics – risk seeing diminishing returns as Google’s AI keeps more eyeballs on Google’s page.
Bottom Line for Law Firms
For attorneys and law firm marketers, all this may sound daunting. The way potential clients find legal services is shifting quickly, and the traditional SEO ROI calculators (traffic → leads → clients) are under pressure. However, by staying informed and adapting, firms can turn this shift to their advantage. The rapid rise of AI in search is a challenge, but it’s also an opportunity for those who move with the tide. Daniel, the founder of Veridictas, often emphasizes looking at these changes not with doom and gloom, but with a strategic eye: How can we make sure our firm is the one Google’s AI loves to quote?
Remember, Google’s core mission is to help users – and those users will still need real lawyers for real legal problems after they get an answer to “What’s the penalty for X?”.
By aligning your online presence with Google’s AI-driven direction, you ensure that when those users do seek professional help, your firm will be prominently in the mix – either as the instant answer that built their trust, or the next click they make when the AI overview nudges them to “learn more.” The firms that adapt now are positioning themselves to not just weather Google’s AI revolution, but to thrive in it.
Sources:
